Menus

White Truffle Lobster Mac and Cheese

Fresh, succulent lobster and aged white Cheddar cheese, tossed with sea shell pasta and topped with a white truffle panko topping

$21

Mahi Bites*

Fresh, locally-caught Mahi Mahi served over a bed of field greens and topped with a Cajun remoulade. Choice of Grilled/Blackened/Jerk/Fried

$16

Fried Calamari

Tender calamari, lightly breaded and fried. Served with a homemade spicy marinara

$14

Conch Fritters

Conch seasoned with island spices, lightly fried and served with a tropical dipping sauce

$14

Homemade Mozzarella

Creamy inside, crunchy outside, melts in your mouth. Laid over homemade spicy marinara and topped with fresh basil and shredded parmesan

$14

Chips and Salsa

Warm tri-color tortilla chips and homemade pico de gallo

$8

Add Guacamole $5

Cheesy Spinach Artichoke Dip

Creamy, full of flavor, chunks of artichoke. Served with warm tortilla chips, sour cream, and pico de gallo

$13

Tuna Nachos**

Fresh Ahi grade tuna served on a bed of wonton crisps topped with a seaweed salad, wasabi aioli, and a teriyaki drizzle

$19

Shrimp Bisque Fries

Seasoned Idaho potato fries topped with our house-made Shrimp Bisque, Applewood smoked bacon, and freshly diced scallions

$13

Coach's Pigskin Nachos**

Slow-roasted BBQ pulled pork, pepper medley, banana peppers, jalapeños, black olives, onions, pico de gallo, sour cream, guacamole, melted Monterey Jack and Cheddar cheese, served over tri-colored tortilla chips

$18

Coconut Crusted Shrimp

Lightly Battered and dusted with sweet coconut then served over a bed of tropical rice and drizzled with a Sweet Thai Chili sauce

$15

JJ 's Original Nachos

Diced poblano and bell peppers, pico di gallo, black olives, banana peppers, melted Monterey Jack and Cheddar cheese, jalapenos, onions, sour cream and guacamole served over tri colored tortilla chips, Add Chicken or Beef $6

$15

Add Chicken or Beef $6

Signature BBQ Chicken Potato Skins

Grilled, marinated chicken smothered with a blend of Monterey Jack, Cheddar cheese, and Applewood smoked bacon all melted to perfection and topped with Captain Morgan BBQ sauce. Served with sour cream and BBQ sauce for dipping

$16

Choose Your Style

BBQ | Sweet Thai Chili | Teriyaki | Garlic Parmesan | Caribbean Jerk | Mild | Medium | Hot | Turkey Point (nuclear)

Choose Your Size

Served with bleu cheese and celery. Extra bleu cheese $0.50

Small ( 8 pc.) $13

Large (16 pc.) $25

Big Chill Brick Oven Roasted Chicken Wings**

Served with grilled onions & focaccia bread

Small (8 pc.) $13

Large (16 pc.) $25

Chili-Rubbed Flank Steak

Thinly sliced flank stead served over roasted corn salsa and topped with an avocado crème fraiche. Served with choice of side

$28

14 oz. Ribeye Steak

Well marbled for peak flavor, deliciously juicy. Served with choice of side

$36

Choose Your Sauce

Garlic Rosemary | Port Wine Reduction | Gorgonzola Roasted Pepper White Wine Reduction | Au Poivre

$3

Oysters on the 1/2 Shell

Fresh Oysters (6 minimum)

$2.50 per Each

Old Bay Peel and Eat

Jumbo 16/20 Shrimp (served hot or cold)

1/2 Order $13

Full Order $25

Oysters Rockefeller

6 prime oysters baked and topped with Applewood smoked bacon, creamed spinach and artichoke, peppers, and fresh mozzarella

$19

Key Largo Smoked Fish Dip

Homemade and served with crackers, celery, carrots, and lemon

$13

Chop Salad**

Chopped Iceberg, spinach, and radicchio tossed with red onion, hearts of palm, green olives, mushrooms, bacon, eggs, croutons, bleu cheese, and lemon basil dressing. Topped with crispy fried onions

$14

The Wedge

1/4 head of Iceberg lettuce, tomato wedges, red onion, and Applewood smoked bacon; drizzled with homemade bleu cheese dressing and topped with bleu cheese crumbles

$13

House Salad

Mixed baby lettuce, grape tomatoes, cucumbers, Applewood smoked bacon, Cheddar cheese, and fresh-baked croutons

$11

Mahi Mahi Salad*

Fresh local Mahi Mahi mesquite grilled over Romaine, fresh spinach, tomato wedges, and gorgonzola cheese. Served with a basil vinaigrette

$18

Classic Caesar Salad

Crisp Romaine hearts tossed with Romano cheese, a creamy dressing, and topped off with shredded Parmesan and baked croutons

$12

New England Clam Chowder

$9

Bimini Conch Chowder

$9

Local Mahi Mahi Sandwich*

Grilled, blackened, jerked, or fried with roasted red pepper mayo and tropical mango coleslaw on a potato bun

$18

Mahi BLT Sandwich*

Mahi Mahi, Applewood smoked bacon, Iceberg lettuce, sliced tomato and avocado on your choice of white, wheat, or rye bread

$20

Substitute Lobster $12

Prime Rib Wrap**

Extra-lean, thinly-sliced prime rib, slowly cooked for 6 hours, served with creamy onion horseradish sauce and melted Swiss cheese in a warm flour tortilla wrap

$19

Fish Tacos*

Fresh local catch grilled, blackened, jerked, or fried with Tropical Mango Coleslaw, pico de gallo, and cilantro cream. Served on 2 warm tortillas

Mahi Mahi $18

Tuna* $19

Snapper $20

Grouper $21

Shrimp $19

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Marinated for 24 hours, then slow roasted for 8 hours before being tossed in our homemade Captain Morgan BBQ sauce. Served on a hoagie roll and garnished with crispy onions and scallions

$14

Big Chill Fish Sandwich* **

Fresh local mahi fried, topped with American cheese and fresh dill sauce on a potato bun. A locals' favorite

$18

Chicken Parmesan Sub

Italian-style chicken cutlet breaded and topped with homemade marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese. Baked in our brick oven and served on a toasted Italian hoagie roll, garnished with fresh basil and shredded Parmesan

$16

Dolphin Reuben*

Local Mahi topped with 1000 Island dressing, Tropical Mango Slaw and melted Swiss. Served on toasted rye bread

$19

Monterey Jack Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken topped with Monterey jack and Cheddar cheese, shredded iceberg, housemade Pico de Gallo and sliced avocado on a potato bun.

$15

Add Bacon $2

Applewood Smoked Bacon Cheddar Burger**

All-American juicy burger topped with Applewood smoked bacon, Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle served on a potato bun

$17

California Burger

You won't miss the meat with our balsamic-marinated Portobello mushroom, grilled to perfection and topped with avocado, arugula, Pepperjack cheese, roasted red pepper, and garlic pesto mayo

$14

Add Burger Patty $7

Hamburger

Thick and juicy Angus beef burger grilled to order with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on a potato bun

$15

Cheeseburger

Black Angus Beef burger topped with your choice of cheese and grilled to perfection. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle on a potato bun

$16

Add Toppings

Add Grilled Onions $2

Add Mushrooms $2

Add Avocado $3

upgrade Sweet Potato fries $4

Garlic Crab Grouper*

Fresh grouper topped with sautéed lump crab meat and fresh garlic in a Key Lime beurre blanc

$37

Captain's Platter

Fresh local Mahi Mahi, shrimp, and a Key Largo lump crab cake. Please choose one preparation per order from baked, grilled, blackened, jerked, or fried

$34

Parmesan Crusted Snapper* **

Fresh local yellowtail snapper crispy and encrusted in Parmesan cheese and buttermilk batter, seasoned and topped with lump crab in a lemon butter beurre blanc

$37

Shrimp with Angel Hair Pasta

Shrimp sautéed with cherry tomatoes, roasted garlic, fresh basil, white wine, and finished with garlic butter

$28

Linguine and Clam Sauce

Whole and chopped clams sautéed in your choice of a white wine garlic butter sauce or a savory red sauce and finished with a touch of fresh basil and crushed red pepper chili flakes

$26

White Truffle Lobster Mac & Cheese

Fresh, succulent 6-oz Florida lobster tail atop aged white Cheddar cheese, tossed with sea shell pasta and topped with with a white truffle panko topping.

$42

Chicken Parmesan

Italian-style chicken cutlet breaded and topped with homemade marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese. Baked in our brick oven and served over angel hair pasta

$24

Loster Lovers Pasta

Fresh Florida lobster in a garlic and white wine pink cream sauce tossed with imported fettuccine pasta and garnished with fresh basil and scallions

$38

Today's Fresh Catch*

Fresh local fish grilled, blackened, jerked, or fried

Mahi Mahi $28

Snapper $31

Grouper (Upon Availability) $32

Fried Shrimp Platter**

Jumbo shrimp lightly breaded then fried golden brown served with housemade cocktail sauce

$27

Coconut Crusted Shrimp

Jumbo shrimp lightly battered and dusted with sweet coconut then fried to a crispy perfection. Served with a Sweet Thai Chili dipping sauce

$29

Fettuccine Alfredo

Imported fettuccine pasta sautéed with roasted garlic, cream, white wine, and Parmesan cheese

$18

Add Herb Roasted Chicken $8

Add Jumbo Shrimp $10

Individual 10" Pie

$9

Each Additional Topping $1.50

Each Specialty Topping $2

Small 12" Pie

$12

Each Additional Topping $1.75

Each Specialty Topping $2.50

Large 16" Pie

$16

Each Additional Topping $2.25

Each Specialty Topping $3.50

Meatball & Ricotta

Sliced meatballs over our traditional pizza

Small 12" Pie $16

Large 16" Pie $21

White Pizza

Mozzarella, Ricotta, and Romano cheese (No Sauce)

Small 12" $16

Large 16" $21

Arugula

Tossed arugula salad over our traditional pizza

Small 12" $16

Large 16" $21

Hawaiian

Pineapple, ham, and fresh garlic

Small 12" $16

Large 16" $21

Fresh Mozzarella Sliced Tomato & Basil

No Sauce

Small 12" $16

Large 18.5" $21

The Italian Fisherman

Lobster meat, clams, shrimp and crab meat

Small 12" $29

Large 16" $41

Pesto Shrimp

Pesto marinated shrimp with mozzarella, Ricotta, fresh basil and topped with roasted garlic chips (FUGETABOUTIT!)

Small 12" $21

Large 16" $28

The Boss

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, onion, mushrooms, sweet pepper medley, and extra cheese (anchovies upon request)

Small 12" $20

Large 16" $27

Meatlovers

Pepperoni, Meatball,Sausage, Ham

Small 12" $19

Large 16" $26

Veggie

Onion, Mushroom, Peppers, Black Olives

Small 12' $18

Large 16" $24

Small

$12

Each Additional Topping $1.50

Each Specialty Topping $2.50

Large

$16

Each Additional Topping $2

Each Specialty Topping $3.50

Small (8 pc.)

$13

Large (16 pc.)

$25

JJ's Original Key Lime Pie**

Buttery pecan toffee crust combined with our freshly squeezed key lime custard. Delicious!

$9

Chocolate Overload Cake

Indulge yourself in four layers of chocolate decadence

$9

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cheesecake**

Ribbons of white chocolate blended with sweet cream cheese and a touch of vanilla, topped with chopped macadamia nuts

$9

Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

$6

Grilled Mahi Mahi Plate*

Grilled and served with French Fries and julienne seasonal vegetables

$14

Grilled Cheese

White bread with American cheese

$8

Chicken Fingers

Lightly breaded and deep fried to golden brown

$9

Grilled Chicken Platter

Grilled chicken breast served with french fries and julienne seasonal vegetables

$11

Fish Fingers

Lightly breaded and deep fried to golden brown

$11

Mini Burgers

Two burgers with Cheddar cheese

$10

Pasta with Butter

Seashell pasta sautéed with warm butter

$8

Key Largo Tea

Captain Pineapple, Captain Coconut, Capitan White, Sour , Pineapple

$12

The Big Chill

The Locals' Choice - Ketel One Citroen, Xrated and Lemonade

$12

The Happy Ending

Bacardi Superior, Key Lime Liquor, Crème of Coconut, Orange and Pineapple Juices in a glass rimmed with Graham Cracker Crumbs

$12

Frozen Drinks

Piña Colada | Strawberry Daiquiri | Rumrunner | Margarita | Mango Daiquiri | Banana Daiquiri All frozen Rum Drinks are made with Bacardi Superior Add a Havana Club Anejo Floater

$12

Perfect Margarita

Patron Silver Tequila, Patron Citronage, Lime Juice

$12

Mango Mojito

Captain Morgan White, Mango Puree, Mint & Lime, Topped with Club Soda

$12

Key Lime Colada

An Island Favorite - Frozen Captain Morgan Pineapple, Key Lime Liquor, Crème of Coconut

$12

Painkiller

Pusser's Rum, Pineapple Juice, Coconut, Orange Juice, Nutmeg

$12

Category 5 Hurricane

Bacardi Superior, Havana Club Anejo,Orange Juice, Pineapple, Grenadine

$12

Blue Lagoon

Grey Goose Vodka, Blue Curacao, Lemonade

$12

Ultimate Bloody Mary

Grey Goose Vodka, Homemade Bloody Mary Mix, Bleu Cheese Olives, Shrimp

$12

Paloma

Don Julio, Sour, Ruby Red

$12

Rum Buckets

Captain Pineapple, Captain White Coconut and Mixed Juices

$14

Vodka Buckets

A Mixture of Smirnoff Vodka, Cranberry, Cherry, Pomegranate, Raspberry, Topped with Fruit Juices

$14

Domestic

Amberbock $4.25

Becks $4.25

Buckler $4.25

Bud Light $4.25

Bud Light Lime $4.25

Coors Light $4.25

Land Shark $4.25

Michelob Ultra $4.25

Miller Lite $4.25

Yuengling $4.25

Import

Amstel Light $5.25

Blue Moon $5.25

Red Stripe $5.25

Corona $5.25

Corona Light $5.25

Guinness $5.25

Heineken $5.25

Heineken Light $5.25

New Castle $5.25

Stella Artois $5.25

Domestic

Budweiser $3

Bud Light $3

Coors Light $3

Miller Lite $3

Yuengling $3

Import/Specialty

Corona Light $4

Key West $4

Stella Artois $4

Craft Draft

Ask your server for Seasonal Selections

Islamorada Ale 5 abv $5.75

Channel Marker IPA 5.1 abv $5.75

Sandbar Sunday 4.7 abv $5.75

Angry Orchard 5 abv $5.75

Blue Moon 5.4 abv $5.75

Lagunitas IPA 6.2 abv $5.75

White Claw $5.25

Pepsi | Diet Pepsi | Lemonade | Dr. Pepper | Crush Orange | Tropicana Lemonade | Fresh Brewed Iced Tea | Arnold Palmer

$3

Cava,Brut Freixenet

Split $7.50

Prosecco, Martini and Rossi

Split $7.50

Brut, Chandon, California

Bottle $33

Veuve Clicquot Yellow Label, France

Bottle $75

Mezzacorona Pinot Grigio

Italy

Glass $7

Bottle $25

Esperto, Pinot Grigio

Italy

Glass $9

Bottle $30

Mondavi Private Select Sauvignon Blanc

California

Glass $7

Bottle $25

Oyster Bay Sauvignon Blanc

Marborough

Glass $8.50

Bottle $30

Cloudy Bay Sauvignon Blanc

New Zealand

Bottle $48

Terrazas Chardonnay

Argentina

Glass $8.50

Bottle $28

Moscato, Villa Pozzi

Italy

Glass $7

Bottle $25

Reisling Chateau St. Michelle

Glass $8

Bottle $28

Kendall Jackson Chardonnay

California

Glass $9

Bottle $30

Terrazas Malbec

Argentina

Glass $7.50

Bottle $28

Chianti, Ruffino

Italy

Split $12.50

Pinot Noir, Cellar 8

California

Glass $7

Bottle $25

Chianti

Verrazzano, Italy

Bottle $45

Pinot Noir, Meiomi

California

Glass $10

Bottle $32

Pinot Noir, Patz and Hall

Sonoma

Bottle $60

Merlot, Glass Mountain

California

Glass $7

Bottle $25

Cabernet, Grey Stone

California

Glass $7.50

Bottle $28

Cabernet, Terrazas

Argentina

Glass $9

Bottle $30

Cabernet, Jordan

Napa, California

Bottle $85